Taylor Frankie Paul's Ex Sues Hulu, Says 'Mormon Wives' Staged Scenes
Dakota Mortensen's defamation suit says producers cut footage of Paul hitting him. He's seeking more than $300,000 from Hulu and two production companies.

Dakota Mortensen says the cameras on "The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives" caught his ex, Taylor Frankie Paul, hitting him with a pizza box, and producers cut it.
That's one of the claims in a defamation suit Mortensen filed Friday in Utah state court against Hulu and the show's two production companies, Jeff Jenkins Productions and Ludwig Productions, Deadline reported. The complaint asks for a jury trial and more than $300,000 in damages, according to Deadline. According to TheWrap, which cited a copy obtained by Salt Lake City station ABC4, the suit says Seasons 3 through 5 showed him "to millions of viewers as a domestic abuser," as a cheater, and as a man who got back at his child's mother by reporting her to child protective services.
His lawyers are careful about what they aren't arguing. The 14-page filing says he "does not complain that a reality program edited his participation unflatteringly," Deadline reported. What it does say is that the producers aired claims of fact they knew were false, or recklessly ignored, and that those episodes ruined his name and his income in the Utah community where he works.
So the suit's complaint isn't that the edit was unkind. It's that the facts were made up. Per TheWrap, the suit says his portrayal was "assembled from staged events and from the deliberate deletion of footage that contradicted the storyline," and that it aired after Mortensen and others had told producers the allegations weren't true.
The examples get specific. At the Season 3 reunion, Mortensen says, he was promised a chance to answer the accusations against him on camera, then his answers were cut, ABC4 reported. He also claims production told Paul she could storm the stage, so a moment that looked spontaneous had been set up.
A big Season 3 plot point was his supposed romance with a friend of Paul's family. That friend put a denial in writing, Mortensen says, and the show never broadcast the letter; in his telling, according to ABC4, "no such relationship existed." He also denies ever calling child protective services on Paul.
Then there's the pizza box, from Season 5. Mortensen says he demanded the footage be included and it was cut anyway. The suit says the one recording of either of them getting physical showed Paul going after him, and that producers hid it from viewers on purpose while he went on being cast as the abuser, TheWrap reported.
The couple's real-life story had already cost the Disney side of the business. In March, ABC pulled Paul's season of "The Bachelorette" days before it was set to premiere, after video surfaced of a 2023 domestic violence incident between the two, for which Paul was arrested, TheWrap reported. That season still hasn't aired.
"Mormon Wives" paused production during a separate domestic assault investigation by Draper City police. In April, the Salt Lake County district attorney declined to charge Paul, saying some of the incidents didn't amount to crimes and the rest lacked enough evidence, according to TheWrap, and filming resumed a week later. No criminal case has been brought against Mortensen over any of those episodes either, according to ABC4. Paul said in September she wouldn't return for the show's sixth season, Deadline reported. The two now hold mutual three-year protective orders and are still fighting over custody of their son, Ever.
According to Deadline, the complaint says Mortensen didn't go straight to court. His lawyers traded letters with counsel for Jeff Jenkins Productions over the alleged falsehoods, and the suit says the producers brushed them off. The filing also points to a steep fall in his online audience and in the money that audience used to bring in, Deadline reported. Mortensen claims the fallout cost him contracts and work and brought thousands of hostile messages, ABC4 reported.
Hulu had no comment for Deadline. Representatives for Hulu and both production companies didn't immediately respond to TheWrap's requests for comment. The three seasons Mortensen is suing over are still streaming on Hulu, which the suit says continues to promote them.
Source: Deadline, retrieved November 15, 2026. Other sources: TheWrap, yahoo.com.
™
Comments 0