Los Angeles, CA
Sections
The LA Globe
FILM REVIEW

Review: Colleen Hoover's 'Verity' Buries Its Real Twists Under Fake Ones

Josh Hartnett shines in Michael Showalter's Colleen Hoover thriller, though red herrings and flashbacks blunt the real twists. 3.5 out of 5.

3 min read
ShareXFacebookEmail
Comments
A movie poster titled 'Verity' with a woman's face with red lipstick in a dark silhouette cut-out, a smaller figure inside, the printed names Anne Hathaway, Dakota Johnson and Josh Hartnett, the tagline 'There is no light where we're going'
The theatrical poster for "Verity" (2026) (Poster: Amazon MGM Studios via Wikipedia)

Somewhere around the third fake-out in "Verity," I stopped bracing for the floor to drop. That's the risk with a thriller that cries wolf. By the time the real wolf shows up, near the end of nearly two hours, I'd already let my guard down.

Michael Showalter's take on Colleen Hoover's bestseller, two years after "It Ends With Us" turned one of her novels into a hit, has the cast to be the best of her movies: Dakota Johnson, Anne Hathaway and Josh Hartnett. For the first 10 minutes it moves like a movie that knows exactly where it's headed. Then it starts faking me out, and it rarely lets up.

Johnson plays Lowen Ashleigh, a struggling New York writer hired to finish a hit book series for Verity Crawford (Hathaway), a bestselling novelist left catatonic after a car accident. Lowen moves into the Crawfords' lakeside house in Vermont with Verity's husband, Jeremy (Hartnett), and their son, Crew, and she finds Verity's unfinished autobiography, full of confessions she can't stop reading. Amazon MGM Studios opened it in theaters on Friday, Oct. 2.

That manuscript is the engine of Hoover's novel, and it's where the movie starts to lose some steam. Nick Antosca's screenplay plays Verity's pages as flashbacks, and too many trips back let the air out of the present: a stranger in someone else's house, working beside a wife who can't speak, for a husband she's drawn to. That's the movie, and the flashbacks keep pulling away from it.

Then the movie fills that house with suspicion that doesn't always go anywhere. Verity's nurse drifts through without much to do, and a few turns seem to exist mostly so the movie can say it turned. A good red herring costs you something when it's cleared away. Too many of these cost the film only time, and each one takes a little punch from the twists still to come.

When those twists do arrive, they're staged a lot like the decoys, so they didn't give me the floor-drop I was waiting for. The movie can still make me jump. When a kid stabs himself in the mouth, I leapt out of my seat and scared the person next to me. I wish more of the reveals had hit me like that.

Part of the problem is pitch. Showalter came up in comedy, and he co-wrote "Wet Hot American Summer", so maybe it's no surprise that "Verity" keeps landing somewhere between a telenovela and a send-up of one. Hathaway plays Verity at full telenovela volume and sometimes past it, but she commits to every note. Alex Cooper and Sean Evans turn up as themselves in podcast cameos. A few shots tip into cheese, most of all one framed off a reflection in glass. More than once I couldn't tell whether I was supposed to gasp or laugh. If you're in on the joke, that may be half the fun.

Hartnett is the one who never tips over. He's great as Jeremy, the husband the whole house turns on, and the louder the movie gets around him, the quieter he plays it. I liked Johnson, too. Her Lowen is the outsider the story follows into that house, wary and a little too curious, and she's the one person whose suspicion the movie should have trusted.

I give it 3.5 out of 5. The cast is strong enough, and the ride wild enough, that I'd still tell a friend who loved the book to go, and plenty of people are: it opened at No. 1 with $32.6 million. I just wish its last turn had knocked the wind out of me. By the time "Verity" got there, the flashbacks and the extra fake-outs had already spent most of the suspicion I brought into that house.

Source: en.wikipedia.org, retrieved October 4, 2026. Other sources: en.wikipedia.org, en.wikipedia.org, en.wikipedia.org, en.wikipedia.org.

Have a tip we should know? Email tips@thelaglobe.com.

Stay in the Orbit

What everyone in L.A. is talking about, twice a week. Mondays and Fridays. Free. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy.

Or follow the Globe on Facebook.

Comments