Los Angeles, CA
Sections
The LA Globe
FILM REVIEW

New 'Hunger Games' Prequel Splits Critics Over Its Killer Meadow

Two pans and two warmer reviews fight over the Haymitch prequel's pastel arena; three of the four sour on its cameo ending.

4 min read
ShareXFacebookEmail
Comments
Moviegoers wait in line under a theater marquee on Hollywood Boulevard at night for the opening of a new Hunger Games movie.
Moviegoers line up outside a Hollywood Boulevard movie palace on opening night. Photo illustration. (Photo illustration: The LA Globe)

The killer meadow at the heart of “The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping” is either the best thing in the movie or proof the series has lost its teeth, depending on which critic you read.

Lionsgate's sixth Hunger Games film, a prequel about the teenage Haymitch Abernathy (Joseph Zada), opened in theaters Friday. Nobody at the Globe has seen it, so what follows rests on four published reviews we merged and weighted equally: two trade pans and two warmer takes from entertainment sites. They fight over the arena, and where they agree, they're harsher than where they fight.

The film adapts Suzanne Collins' 2025 novel, and IndieWire says the script sticks to it faithfully. It's set 24 years before the first movie, at the 50th Games, a Quarter Quell that reaps twice the usual number of tributes, Screen Rant explains. Haymitch is pulled in on his 16th birthday after a chosen tribute runs and is killed, Deadline's review says, alongside Maysilee Donner (Mckenna Grace) and Wyatt Callow (Ben Wang).

Then comes the meadow. In Deadline on Nov. 17, Damon Wise counted up the hazards: toxic plants, butterflies that carry a charge and beavers with a taste for people, unless they were rats, which he couldn't make out even in Imax. He called it all “about as terrifying as being mauled to death by The Wonderful World of Disney.”

Ryan Lattanzio, in IndieWire's C- review the same day, liked the blueprint more than the build. Poisonous streams and a deadly force field give the arena the feel of a dark-mirror “Charlie and the Chocolate Factory,” he wrote, until the computer effects swamp it.

The other two looked at the same field and liked what they saw. Morgan Stradling of That Park Place, in a 7.5/10 review published on Yahoo Nov. 19, called the Games the most enjoyable part of the film, a pastel fairy-tale meadow until the gong sounds. She said the nearly 2-hour-40-minute runtime gives them the room the book didn't, and in Screen Rant on Nov. 17, Alex Harrison found the arena both beautiful and deadly.

But Harrison's good review carries a concession that sounds a lot like Wise. “The Hunger Games has lost its ability to be harrowing,” he wrote, calling the film lighter than its tragedies deserve. Wise had gone further, saying there's no peril at all and that the series has reached its High School Musical moment, when everyone gets a participation prize.

Pretty and deadly isn't the same as scary, and of the four critics, only Stradling came away calling the film suspenseful.

Zada gets gentler treatment than the character he plays. Wise said Zada's doe-eyed charm got him through at least two hours of a film he found more tedious as it went. Lattanzio called the performance charming but Haymitch a cog built to line the prequel up with the older films, and Stradling, who praised Zada's take on Woody Harrelson's role, blamed the book for an underwhelming hero.

The warmer reviews found their heart elsewhere. Stradling says Grace, who also plays Maysilee's twin, steals the show. Harrison predicts audiences will love Maysilee more than any other new character, and he names Jesse Plemons as Plutarch Heavensbee the film's clear standout.

Lattanzio doesn't expect any of this to dent the box office. He predicted a hysterical amount of money for a series he called mostly critic-proof, and Deadline reported the film's preview grosses were the second-best of the franchise. On Rotten Tomatoes, about two-thirds of critics' reviews are positive, which makes the two pans here the minority, and the audience score sits at 95%.

Most of them close ranks on the last few minutes. Lattanzio called the cameos tacked onto the end depressing fan service, and the whole film “a dreary slog.” Harrison said the fan-service ending soured him on where the franchise goes next, and that the wisest move might be to quit while it's ahead.

Stradling is the holdout, promising fans Easter eggs and returning favorites, and she calls the film a tragic yet satisfying final blow that closes out the series.

The critics' verdict: a prequel with a likable new Haymitch that half these critics enjoyed, and an ending three of the four took as a sour note. Wise watched the original cast turn up at the end and couldn't shake the feeling they'd come “to pay their last respects.”

Source: Deadline, retrieved November 20, 2026. Other sources: IndieWire, screenrant.com, yahoo.com, Rotten Tomatoes.

Have a tip we should know? Email tips@thelaglobe.com.

Stay in the Orbit

What everyone in L.A. is talking about, twice a week. Mondays and Fridays. Free. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy.

Or follow the Globe on Facebook.

Comments