Los Angeles, CA
Sections
The LA Globe
FILM REVIEW

Critics Can't Agree Whether Johnny Depp's Scrooge Is a Comeback

Ti West's horror-tinged 'A Christmas Carol' won over two of five trade critics, and the split runs straight through Depp.

3 min read
ShareXFacebookEmail
Comments
Johnny Depp, photographed in August 2026.
Johnny Depp, photographed in August 2026. (ManoSolo13241324 / public domain)

Five critics reviewed "Ebenezer," Ti West's horror-tinged take on "A Christmas Carol" starring Johnny Depp as Scrooge. They agreed on nearly everything except Johnny Depp.

We read the five reviews that Deadline, The Hollywood Reporter, IndieWire, TheWrap and Variety posted Nov. 12, the day before Paramount released the PG-13 film in theaters, and weighed them equally. Nobody here has seen "Ebenezer." This is a report on what those critics wrote, not a review of our own. Two of them liked Depp's Scrooge. The other three ranged from lukewarm to frozen.

About the movie itself they barely argue. Paramount sold it as a story nobody had heard. Variety's Guy Lodge said the poster's pitch all but lies, because the film turns out to be a mostly straight retelling. Deadline's Pete Hammond wrote that West and screenwriter Nathaniel Halpern respect Dickens too much to rebuild the tale, whatever the ads claim. THR's Frank Scheck opened by asking whether the world needed another version and decided it didn't, really.

What they like is the haunting. Andrea Riseborough's corpse-pale Ghost of Christmas Past and Tramell Tillman's decaying Ghost of Christmas Present get some of the warmest lines in four of the five reviews, and TheWrap's Amelia Emberwing called Tillman the film's diamond in the rough. Lodge named production designer Eve Stewart the film's MVP for her rotting, mildewed London.

The gloom has a cost. Scheck thought this might be the first version that isn't really fit for small children. Lodge called it too scary for many kids and too familiar for many adults, which in his view leaves the film's commercial hopes riding on one gamble: Depp.

That's where the critics part. Scheck said Depp's broad turn most resembles Albert Finney's in the 1970 musical "Scrooge," said the star's charisma wins through and called the redemption finale a delight. THR's bottom line: "Gets the ghostly job done." Hammond went further and wrote that Depp finds more humanity in Scrooge than earlier versions did, well before the happy ending.

IndieWire's David Ehrlich gave it a C- and called the performance "an advent calendar of empty affectations." He wrote that he believed Depp neither as the glowering miser nor as the beaming convert. Emberwing heard Jack Sparrow's cadence and bluster under the Scrooge costume. Lodge landed in between: a solid, by-the-book Scrooge with the odd ripe line reading, nowhere near the pain of Alastair Sim's 1951 version.

The split follows something outside the frame. Both admirers graded the film partly as a comeback. Scheck wrote that it achieves its apparent goal of putting Depp back on the A-list. Hammond closed by comparing the star's rough patch to Scrooge's own: "this gifted actor is seeing the light again." Ehrlich put the word comeback in quotation marks. Lodge, who described Depp as returning to studio films after eight years on the A-list blacklist, saw the divide coming: "How much viewers are individually rooting for the star himself may determine how much they share in the film's warm-and-fuzzy payoff."

The critics' verdict: a handsome, spooky, faithful "Christmas Carol" that none of the five called necessary, with a Scrooge whose change of heart lands about as hard as you want Depp's to.

Look at the finale, where Scrooge shows up at nephew Fred's (Sam Claflin) with a goose. Scheck saw Depp relax into real comedy there. Emberwing saw Claflin's stunned reaction almost spark something before it fizzled. Ehrlich doubted the fire had ever gone out at all.

Source: Variety, retrieved November 13, 2026. Other sources: Deadline, The Hollywood Reporter, TheWrap, IndieWire.

Have a tip we should know? Email tips@thelaglobe.com.

Stay in the Orbit

What everyone in L.A. is talking about, twice a week. Mondays and Fridays. Free. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy.

Or follow the Globe on Facebook.

Comments