GTA 6 Guides Can't Agree Whether to Trust Halifax
In the Dubious Provenance mission, Game8 says don't trust him, while GameRant and PowerPyx say trusting is how you reach the final part.

Grand Theft Auto VI came out Thursday on PS5 and Xbox Series X|S, and by Sunday the guide sites were split over one man: Benedict Halifax, a British antiques dealer in a Chapter 3 mission called Dubious Provenance. Videogameschronicle.com put the question right in the headline of its walkthrough Sunday: should you trust Halifax? Mild spoilers for the mission follow.
Jason and Lucia bring their mystery statue to a shop in Capri, and the owner, Evelyn, won't touch it because she thinks it's either a great fake or stolen, PowerPyx's walkthrough says. That's when Halifax finds them on the street with a side deal: he'll quietly put a value on the statue, and they can hold his watch until he does. Every guide says to hand the statue over. If players refuse and never use the optional callback, PowerPyx says, the mission's last two parts vanish when Chapter 3 ends.
The real fight is the second choice. Players track Halifax to a motel, where he asks for more time with the statue. GameRant says to trust him, because that opens the third and final part, and taking the statue back ends the mission early. PowerPyx agrees. Game8 calls "Don't Trust" the best choice. Its version says trusting him just leaves players waiting on a call he never makes, and both paths end with Halifax attacking Evelyn and running.
Put those together and trusting him is the only answer no guide says locks players out. By Game8's account, the worst it costs is a wait. The payoff is what GameRant calls "a long and hilarious chase," plus a stash Game8 puts at $2,800 in jewelry and cash, along with a '32 Hustler. PowerPyx puts the stash at about $2,500. Game8 says shooting Halifax at the end raises the player's criminal profile, and sparing him lowers it.
The guides don't even agree on which door he's behind. Game8 puts him in Room 111 on the motel's east side, while PowerPyx sends players to an upstairs room on the west. And according to Game8, he's conning them either way.
Source: powerpyx.com, retrieved November 22, 2026. Other sources: gamerant.com, game8.co.
™
Comments 0