Los Angeles, CA
Sections
The LA Globe
WHERE TO EAT

For Old-School Santa Maria Barbecue, Drive to the Original Hitching Post

The Ostini family has run the place since 1952, and a 10-ounce sirloin dinner costs $43 before 6 p.m.

3 min read
ShareXFacebookEmail
Comments
A red wooden building with a yellow sign reading The Hitching Post, parked black and white cars in front, and a blue sky with clouds above.
The Hitching Post building in Casmalia, California, photographed in 2023. (Missvain / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0)

The first steak on the Hitching Post's beef menu in Casmalia isn't tri-tip. It's top sirloin, cut by hand and cooked over local red oak: $40 for 7 ounces and $62 for 15, according to the dinner menu the restaurant posts on its site, as it read Friday.

That order is why it's my pick for anyone heading up the coast for Santa Maria-style barbecue. LAist traced the Central Coast style back to the cattle ranches of the 1830s in an explainer published Thursday. Citing Lompoc butcher Bruce Nix, it puts the shift toward tri-tip in the late 1960s. The older pits ran on prime rib first, and after it on thick sirloin cut for the skewer.

The Ostini family has run the Hitching Post since 1952, more than a decade before that switch, and the menu still calls beef its specialty since that year. Tri-tip doesn't appear anywhere on the posted dinner menu.

The style itself is short on rules and strict about them: red oak coals, a dry rub, no barbecue sauce, and a grate with no lid that cranks down to sear and up to finish. Nicholas Priedite, who runs a barbecue truck in Los Alamos, described the method to LAist as something between grilling and smoking. The Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce has trademarked "Santa Maria Barbecue."

At the Hitching Post, the steak doesn't arrive alone. Per the menu, every dinner opens with a bay shrimp cocktail, a fresh vegetable tray, salad and garlic bread. Fries, a baked potato or grilled vegetables ride along with the meat, and the meal closes on coffee or tea plus ice cream or sherbet. That's a full old-fashioned steak dinner, so the $46 for a 10-ounce sirloin covers a lot more than the meat.

I'd go early. The twilight menu serves complete dinners every night until 6 p.m., and the same 10-ounce sirloin drops to $43. I'd add the grilled artichoke, $17, which the menu calls its most popular appetizer, along with a promise no copywriter could improve: "try it once and you'll know why."

Just don't order the 30- to 32-ounce bone-in rib chop, $95, cooked all the way through. The menu asks, politely, for no medium well or well done.

If the name rings a bell, credit the movies. Alexander Payne's 2004 film "Sideways" featured the Hitching Post II in Buellton, which the family opened in 1986 and Frank Ostini Jr. runs, according to the restaurant's history page. Buellton got the close-up. Casmalia has the original.

Reservations are taken only by phone or in person, at (805) 937-6151, the restaurant says.

It's for whoever's heading north and wants Santa Maria barbecue the way it ran before tri-tip took over: sirloin at the top of the menu and red oak under every entree.

Source: LAist, retrieved November 13, 2026. Other sources: hitchingpost1.com, hitchingpost1.com (2), hitchingpost1.com (3).

Have a tip we should know? Email tips@thelaglobe.com.

Stay in the Orbit

New L.A. spots and the week’s best stories, in your inbox. Mondays and Fridays. Free. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy.

Or follow the Globe on Facebook.

Comments