Los Angeles, CA
Sections
The LA Globe
Opinion

Eleven Democrats Voted No on Jeffries. Good. Make Him Earn the Gavel.

Hakeem Jeffries won his party's speaker nomination 251-11, and the holdouts are the reason he's already moved on Medicare.

3 min read
ShareXFacebookEmail
Comments
Hakeem Jeffries, photographed in 2021.
Hakeem Jeffries, photographed in 2021. (Office of Representative Hakeem Jeffries / public domain)

Hakeem Jeffries is one floor vote from a gavel no Black American has ever held, and 11 Democrats in his own caucus just voted no. Good. I hope he treats those 11 votes as a to-do list.

House Democrats picked Jeffries as their speaker nominee 251 to 11 on Wednesday, in a secret ballot lawmakers cast through an app on their phones, Time reported. My argument is that the 11 aren't a mutiny. They're the caucus doing its job at the exact moment its leverage peaks: right after a landslide, and right before the man at the top becomes President Trump's chief opponent in Washington.

Jeffries built the ballot they used. Some allies wanted him nominated by acclamation, with no tally at all, and he insisted on a recorded vote so members could register a yes or a no, as the caucus did for Nancy Pelosi after 2018, NBC News reported. You can't design a ballot for dissent and then wave off the people who used it.

The best argument against the holdouts is that a split caucus is a gift to Trump. The record doesn't back it up. When Democrats last took back the House, in 2018, 32 of 239 caucus ballots went against Pelosi, who won roughly 85 percent, Newsweek noted. She went on to oversee two impeachments of Trump, Time reported. Jeffries walked out with about 96 percent. If 32 no votes didn't cripple Pelosi, 11 aren't a crisis.

And the margin for pressure is wide. Democrats are on track for 259 House seats, the biggest majority in 35 years, NBC News projects. A party that wins like that doesn't owe its leader a coronation. It's owed an answer about what the majority is for.

Seven incoming progressives put their names to that question in a joint statement, NBC News reported: Claire Valdez and Darializa Avila Chevalier of New York, Adam Hamawy of New Jersey, Melat Kiros of Colorado, Donavan McKinney of Michigan, Chris Rabb of Pennsylvania and Frederick Haynes of Texas. Haynes woke up sick and missed the vote, his office said, Time reported.

They listed Medicare for All, ICE, money in politics and Gaza. "While we have seen meaningful progress, there is still work to be done," they wrote.

That phrase, meaningful progress, is the whole case. The day before the vote, Jeffries backed lowering the Medicare eligibility age and adding dental, vision and hearing coverage, Time reported, and Bernie Sanders said the package looked like the first stage of his own single-payer plan. I don't believe that move happens without a push. The holdouts are the push.

Jeffries doesn't see it that way. Asked about the 11, he told reporters, "Our job is to fight MAGA extremism, not each other," according to NBC News. Asked whether he'd move left on their issues, he wouldn't commit, Time reported.

The dissent wasn't free, either. Rep.-elect Don Leonard of Ohio said in a video last week that senior Democrats had warned they'd make his life a "living hell" if he didn't back Jeffries, Time reported, and on Wednesday he posted a picture of his ballot anyway. Rep. Josh Gottheimer of New Jersey wrote on X before the vote that if a historic majority wasn't enough for a few members, "then let them vote 'no.'" They did, and some said so in public.

None of that takes anything from the history. Jeffries grew up in Crown Heights, Brooklyn, and for his first 12 years his congresswoman was Shirley Chisholm, he said at Wednesday's news conference. No Black American has ever held the job that sits second in line to the presidency, and that deserves cheering.

Jeffries says the results speak for themselves. They do. The full House votes Jan. 3, and the 251 are already his. The 11 are the only ones still asking him what the majority is for.

Source: thehill.com.

Source: time.com, retrieved November 18, 2026. Other sources: NBC News, newsweek.com.

Have a tip we should know? Email tips@thelaglobe.com.

Stay in the Orbit

The best of L.A. in two emails a week: where to eat, what to do, what everyone’s talking about. Mondays and Fridays. Free. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy.

Or follow the Globe on Facebook.

Comments